Banx Broker

4.1(420)

BaFin

comdirect

4.4(1800)

BaFin

Banx Broker vs comdirect

Head-to-Head Comparison 2026

Our Verdict

comdirect has a higher rating of 4.4/5 compared to Banx Broker (4.1/5). comdirect offers 7 instrument types, while Banx Broker offers 6. The minimum deposit is lower at comdirect with 0 €. comdirect has been in the market since 1994, making it the more experienced provider. Execution speed: Banx Broker ~25 ms (über IBKR-Routing), comdirect ~30 ms (Xetra), ~80 ms (Tradegate).

Comparison Table

Criteria	Banx Broker	comdirect
Rating	4.1/5 (420 reviews)	4.4/5 (1800 reviews)✓
Regulation	BaFin	BaFin
Fees	from €3.90 per stock order, from $2 per US option	€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)
Min. Deposit	3.000 €	0 €
Instruments	Stocks, Options, Futures, Forex, ETFs, CFDs	Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives
Platforms	TWS, Banx App, IBKR Mobile	comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader
Options Trading	Yes, comprehensive options trading via IB	Yes, Eurex options trading available
Execution Speed	~25 ms (über IBKR-Routing)	~30 ms (Xetra), ~80 ms (Tradegate)
Founded	2014	1994
Headquarters	Düsseldorf	Quickborn

Detailed Comparison

Fee Comparison

Banx Broker: from €3.90 per stock order, from $2 per US option. Minimum deposit: 3.000 €.

comdirect: €4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90). Minimum deposit: 0 €.

Execution Quality

Banx Broker

Execution: ~25 ms (über IBKR-Routing)

comdirect

Execution: ~30 ms (Xetra), ~80 ms (Tradegate)

Product Range

Banx Broker (6 categories)

StocksOptionsFuturesForexETFsCFDs

comdirect (7 categories)

StocksETFsOptionsFuturesFundsBondsDerivatives

Trading Platforms

Banx Broker

TWS
Banx App
IBKR Mobile

comdirect

comdirect App
comdirect Web
ProTrader

Regulation & Security

Banx Broker is regulated by BaFin (HQ: Düsseldorf).

comdirect is regulated by BaFin (HQ: Quickborn).

Who Is It For?

Banx Broker

Introducing broker with competitive rates for active traders

✓ Access to international markets

✓ Comprehensive options trading

✓ German customer service

✗ Minimum deposit €3,000

✗ Complex platform for beginners

comdirect

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

✓ Eurex options trading available

✓ Full bank with checking account

✓ Comprehensive educational resources

✗ Higher fees than neobrokers

✗ Custody fee without activity

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Banx Broker or comdirect cheaper?

Banx Broker charges from €3.90 per stock order, from $2 per US option. comdirect charges €4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90). The minimum deposit is 3.000 € at Banx Broker and 0 € at comdirect.

Which broker offers more products: Banx Broker or comdirect?

Banx Broker offers Stocks, Options, Futures, Forex, ETFs, CFDs. comdirect offers Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives.

Which broker is better regulated?

Banx Broker is regulated by BaFin. comdirect is regulated by BaFin. Banx Broker has BaFin regulation, which is particularly advantageous for German investors. comdirect has BaFin regulation, which is particularly advantageous for German investors.

Is Banx Broker or comdirect better for beginners?

Banx Broker has a minimum deposit of 3.000 € and offers TWS, Banx App, IBKR Mobile as platforms. comdirect has a minimum deposit of 0 € and offers comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader. comdirect has the lower entry barrier.

Banx Broker vs comdirect: Which broker is better overall?

The choice between Banx Broker (4.1/5, 420 reviews) and comdirect (4.4/5, 1800 reviews) depends on your needs. Banx Broker: Introducing broker with competitive rates for active traders. comdirect: Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading.

Banx Broker

Introducing broker with competitive rates for active traders

Open Account →

From 3.000 € min. deposit

comdirect

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

Open Account →

From 0 € min. deposit

Banx Broker read review →comdirect read review →