comdirect

4.4(1800)

BaFin

S Broker

3.8(620)

BaFin

comdirect vs S Broker

Head-to-Head Comparison 2026

Our Verdict

comdirect has a higher rating of 4.4/5 compared to S Broker (3.8/5). comdirect has been in the market since 1994, making it the more experienced provider.

Comparison Table

Criteria	comdirect	S Broker
Rating	4.4/5 (1800 reviews)✓	3.8/5 (620 reviews)
Regulation	BaFin	BaFin
Fees	€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)	€4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99)
Min. Deposit	0 €	0 €
Instruments	Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives	Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives
Platforms	comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader	S Broker App, S Broker Web, Marktinvestor pro
Options Trading	Yes, Eurex options trading available	Yes, Eurex trading available
Founded	1994	2001
Headquarters	Quickborn	Wiesbaden

Detailed Comparison

Fee Comparison

comdirect: €4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90). Minimum deposit: 0 €.

S Broker: €4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99). Minimum deposit: 0 €.

Product Range

comdirect (7 categories)

StocksETFsOptionsFuturesFundsBondsDerivatives

S Broker (7 categories)

StocksETFsOptionsFuturesFundsBondsDerivatives

Trading Platforms

comdirect

comdirect App
comdirect Web
ProTrader

S Broker

S Broker App
S Broker Web
Marktinvestor pro

Regulation & Security

comdirect is regulated by BaFin (HQ: Quickborn).

S Broker is regulated by BaFin (HQ: Wiesbaden).

Who Is It For?

comdirect

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

✓ Eurex options trading available

✓ Full bank with checking account

✓ Comprehensive educational resources

✗ Higher fees than neobrokers

✗ Custody fee without activity

S Broker

The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group

✓ Sparkassen security and trust

✓ Eurex options trading available

✓ Wide product range

✗ Higher fees than neobrokers

✗ Custody fee without activity

Frequently Asked Questions

Is comdirect or S Broker cheaper?

comdirect charges €4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90). S Broker charges €4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99). The minimum deposit is 0 € at comdirect and 0 € at S Broker.

Which broker offers more products: comdirect or S Broker?

comdirect offers Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives. S Broker offers Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives.

Which broker is better regulated?

comdirect is regulated by BaFin. S Broker is regulated by BaFin. comdirect has BaFin regulation, which is particularly advantageous for German investors. S Broker has BaFin regulation, which is particularly advantageous for German investors.

Is comdirect or S Broker better for beginners?

comdirect has a minimum deposit of 0 € and offers comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader as platforms. S Broker has a minimum deposit of 0 € and offers S Broker App, S Broker Web, Marktinvestor pro. comdirect has the lower entry barrier.

comdirect vs S Broker: Which broker is better overall?

The choice between comdirect (4.4/5, 1800 reviews) and S Broker (3.8/5, 620 reviews) depends on your needs. comdirect: Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading. S Broker: The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group.

comdirect

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

Open Account →

From 0 € min. deposit

S Broker

The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group

Open Account →

From 0 € min. deposit

comdirect read review →S Broker read review →